About Us
The Legend of the Perfect Slice
From the Queen Mary II to the Streets of Riverhead—Authentic NY Tradition Since 1975.
Sergio’s Pizza wasn’t just born; it was carried across the Atlantic. The tradition began in 1968, when Sergio immigrated to the United States aboard the Queen Mary II, bringing with him a passion for Old World flavor and a vision for the perfect New York pie.
In 1975, during the golden age of the modern New York pizza scene, that vision became a reality. While many claim “authenticity,” Sergio’s lives it. Our original Riverhead, NY location remains a local landmark to this day, serving as the blueprint for every kitchen we open.
As we grow beyond New York, our mission stays the same: to honor the craft Sergio started nearly five decades ago. We don’t just make pizza; we preserve a legacy.